Arizona Schools - Did They Overreact?

In the news recently, a middle school student - aare pro-active in the education and prevention of
14 year old boy, to be precise - was suspendedviolence in the schools. They believe that such a
from Arizona Schools because of a drawing hepolicy, and the punishments, should be on view for
made while sitting in class. No teacher wants tothe world to see. They feel that this will frighten
find his or her student doodling, but must admitthe students into behaving themselves.
that not all students will be as enamored of theirIn fact, this message conflicts with the reasons
subject as the teacher is.zero-tolerance policies are in place in such
The Arizona Schools district the boy attends hassystems as the ones in Arizona Schools.
a zero tolerance policy concerning weapons; thisSupporters believe that the fear of being punished
includes drawing them, or even writing aboutwill "scare them straight.
them. In response to the Columbine massacre inDetractors to zero-tolerance policies in Arizona
1999, most Arizona Schools have some versionSchools and elsewhere have many concerns.
of such a policy in place. (Approximately 96% ofThey worry that the policies are unfair, rigid,
all Arizona Schools have a zero-tolerance policy.)create fear for students, and infringe upon a
Understandably, schools need to send theperson's right to express themselves. While it's
message that it is not okay to bring weapons toimportant to have a safe and secure learning
school. Nobody wants to see another Columbine.environment, it's easy to see that individual
We must do all in our power to stop the violence,consideration should be given to some situations
and this must include educating students aboutlike the one involving the student from Arizona
the harm an atmosphere of fear can do. StudentsSchools. Those opposed to zero-tolerance policies
who go to school every day afraid for their liveslike the one in place for Arizona Schools object
because they don't know if they'll be attacked orbecause of the probability of punishing students
not are not learning, which is the principle purposewho may have made mistakes, as opposed to
for attending school in the first place. Arizonathose planning to commit a criminal act. A
Schools understand this, and have sent the14-year-old boy (or girl) is an enigma; peer
message that they will tolerate no weapons, inpressure, work load at school, and wildly
any form, even on paper.fluctuating hormones are all new challenges that
Supporters of zero-tolerance policies in place inthese young teens have to deal with. These kids
Arizona Public Schools (and across the nation) sayaren't known for their excellent decision making
that this sends the message that the schools areskills; the case of the Arizona Schools student is
concerned about the safety of their students, andan example of this.